Skip to main content

Good Intention, Bad Idea

Updated 1.29.2014 - Last night President Obama stated in his state of the unior address that he believes that minumum wage should be increased to $10.10 an hour. This is a biref illustration to demonstrate what this action would do

Hey y'all, today I've got another post about the math of politics. So pay attention or leave now.
 
If you keep up with the news at all you'll know that President Obama proposed a minimum wage increase . Although in theory this sounds like a great idea it's really not and I'm going to break down why. My first job out of college was in staffing so I'm pretty familiar with the type of work and pay rates that might go on in a typical warehouse - an example of a work environment where you would find minimum wage employees. We're going to go with the tried and true business school scenario that our warehouse is for a widget company. So here goes . . .
 
Here is the list of positions, the pay rate, # of positions and annual position cost for the warehouse:

movers $7.75 20 $322,400.00
packers $9 40 $748,800.00
forklift $12 8 $199,680.00
team lead $14 10 $291,200
office support $16 5 $166,400.00
area manager $18 4 $149,760
warehouse manager $24 1 $49,920.00

 
This widget warehouse has a 35% wages to sales ratio and sells 1 million widgets a year - without overwhelming you with too much math this means that the price of a widget is $5.55.
 
Congress then enacts legislation that the minimum wage be increased to $10.10 an hour. Hurray, all the movers get an increase! But it's not that simple, because packing is harder than moving - so the packers get an increase and so on and so on. So now the wage costs looks like this:

movers 20 10.10 $420,160.00
packers 40 $12.00 $998,400.00
forklift 8 $14.00 $232,960.00
team lead 10 $16.00 $332,800.00
office support 5 $18.00 $187,200.00
area manager 4 $20.00 $166,400.00
warehouse manager 1 $26.00 $54,080.00

Although wages have increased the company will maintain a 35% wage to sales ratio - because that's what companies do. The price of a widget is now $6.69.
 
You'll notice that although each position got a raise, the increase was smaller and smaller as the position rank increased, this is how it works in the real world - do not expect a raise if you make above minumum wage anbd it is increased.  This is how it happens in the real world - everyone will not get the 28.77% increase the movers got.
 
So now we can do a comparison of every one's current annual earning and their new earnings with the increase and we can see how many widgets everyone can afford.

Now Minimum Wage Increase Widgets Per Year
movers $16,120.00 2904 movers $21,008.00 3140 236
packers $18,720.00 3373 packers $24,960.00 3730 357
forklift $24,960.00 4580 forklift $29,120.00 4352 -228
team lead $29,120.00 5247 team lead $33,280.00 4974 -273
office support $33,280.00 5996 office support $37,440.00 5596 -400
area manager $37,440.00 6746 area manager $41,600.00 6218 -528
warehouse manager $49,920.00 8995 warehouse manager $54,080.00 8084 -911
37841 36094 -1747


 
Notice that although the majority of the employees can now afford more widgets the total number of widgets sold went down as the higher earning individuals did not receive an earning increase that matched the increase in widget cost. Since less widgets are being sold the company will now reduce their staff. As a result of all of this here is the final result:
 
5 movers and packers lost their job - they now get $ from the government to buy widgets
55 movers and packers can afford more widgets and are better off
28 "skilled employees" received pay increases but can afford less widgets and are worse off
 
So, while a majority of the people are better off, the widget society as a whole has declined in it's position. And again, as I stated in my conservative values post, the more skills one has and the harder one works to increase standing - the more one is punished by government's policies. And since to read this blog you must a. know how to read b. work from or possess a computer / smart phone chances are one of those skilled workers is YOU!


 


 


 


 


 
 

 

   
 

Comments

  1. That Sucks..... Why did we pay for a college education again?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Vi Peel

2018 Update: Hello Internet! Welcome to my most popular blog post - I presume you're here because you're considering getting a facial peel. Please keep in mind this is an old post and my photo quality is not great. Please feel free to read and enjoy but I do want to let you know that as the years have passed I have taken a more proactive approach with my skin care and I do not get frequent peels. If you'd like to see my modern approach to skincare check out some of my other beauty posts and I'd love for you to connect with me on Instagram to keep up with my latest and greatest recommendations.
___________________________________________________________________________________

Hello! So I got my first Vi Peel which I was super excited about. Since the Botox post was popular I figure y'all would like this too. Besides, it's well established I'm beyond any sense of privacy or shame here.
I got my first peel years ago - a mild Glycolic peel added onto my fac…

What’s in the bag : Toiletry Essentials to Pack for Your Next Trip

I’ve  been traveling so much lately so I’ve pretty much got packing down to a science. Planning for a trip can be stressful so I’m here to make it a little easier for you and talk about the necessities, today were specifically talking about what’s in the toiletry bag. As a special treat I have teamed up with Smile Brilliant for a giveaway at the end of this post!!! When thinking about necessities I first think about the things I don’t need - hotels always have shampoo, conditioner and a hairdryer so I never bring my own to save space.  I then think about what items I use at home that I can go without for the week vs. what I use everyday. I also try to think about  products that are good for multipurpose; facial oil is a great example as I use it for a makeup remover at night , a moisturizer in the morning and I also use a small amount on the ends of my hair. Through this I’ve been able to narrow it down to only ten items.
1. Hairbrush

2. Deodorant

3. Toothbrush

4. Toothpaste

5. Facia…

Plum Paper Designs - Fitness Insert

I know I say this every year but this year I also want to make wellness / fitness a priority. It's hard for me to get in the mindset of making it important because quite frankly it's not something my doctor gets onto me about. But during 2015 I've been making a switch to a more natural lifestyle and that has put fitness back at my top of mind. So, for $4.50 I got the fitness section added onto my Plum Paper Designs Planner 
Here's what's inside: 

A summary sheet at the front: 

A monthly layout for 12 months
Weight Loss Tracker at the Back 

I LOVE the monthly layout! First off, having a hydration tracker for each day is going to be so nice. I also love the idea of holding myself accountable to writing down an activity (or excuse) each day. Most of all I love the recognition that each month will have different goals and includes some note sections ; one thing I hear a lot form people who successfully got fit was that they had some kind of tracking and were able to go back…

Top Ten Trends for Fall and What to Buy Now

I received several questions about the Nordstrom sale and this year I really felt like I would bite the bullet and make a post with recommendations and while I see myself always browsing the sale to see what's up and I'm not closed to doing a round up post in the future after reviewing this year's sale I just can't find the patience to put an entire post together. I always want this blog to be a place where I am authentic and real and not just a place to spew out what's popular but rather what trends speak to me. And I hate to disappoint people , I'm very flattered that there have been people to reach out and ask about my recommendations but I don't want to recommend things just for the sake of recommending things. I prefer to shop in season and with the weather in Memphis I just won't be wearing fall items until late October. Plus, a lot of the items I saw in the sale I liked are similar to items I already own and I don't need to be buying duplic…

Sensible Portions

I'm Sometimes you have to recognize your strengths and when it's time to outsource . For me a healthy lifestyle is not a strength. I love the idea of eating small healthy meals and working out everyday but then I get hangry and eat anything in sight. Or I have a busy weekend and don't have time to meal prep, and then I'm screwed for the week and one bad week turns into a bad month, and a bad year and a decade of gaining weight. So, when a sorority sister posted a meal plan she had found success with I was very interested. Shaun and I tried a similar program last year but it was very expensive ($170 for one person for 5 days) That's a great investment if you need to lose 10 or 20 lbs but when you have a lot to lose you need a long term plan that is viable from a time, nutrition and financial aspect. 
Long term it's still pricey but I was very impressed with the value and results of sensible portions and decided to give it a try. Like most meal plans the plan is …