Skip to main content

A Tale of Two Cities

Well, I survived the annual screwing by Uncle Sam. Bye bye money that could have bought a lot of Lilly. I'm ticked off this year because some of my deductible expenses exceeded the allowable deductible cap so I had more income taxed than I should have if the system was fair, boo! But anyways, my sorority sister SM made a comment on my FB post on also getting screwed on her state income tax. God Bless the great state of TN for our conservative legislature and no income tax. But it got me to thinking, even though I do pay less taxes I also make less than my yankee friends, am I really winning here in the south? Any y'all know how I answered that question, I graphed it. :)
 
Ok, so we have two sweet, nice looking girls in the same sorority and upon graduation they tearfully hug goodbye and go their separate ways. One moved up to NYC and the other back to her hometown of Memphis. By age 30 NYC girl is making $100,000 and Memphis girl is making $55,000 (I just picked 100,000 as the NYC salary to keep it even then looked up the type of job that would pay that and found the Memphis salary). Both are on the company insurance plan and pay the flat single person contribution costs. Both girls are smart and take advantage of their 401K and set aside 6% of their income. Now NYC girl winds up paying 25% of her income in state and federal taxes while Memphis girl is paying 15%. Side note, why is NYC so full of democrats given this horrible tax rate?
 
With their take home pay both girls also set aside 10% in personal savings. Memphis girl is able to keep her total housing costs at 35% of her income while NYC girl needs to go to 40% to live in a safe neighborhood and have more than a closet. NYC girl spends an average of $20 a day on cabs while Memphis girl has a car and buys gas. Both girls buy groceries and have a nice dinner and drinks with friends once a week. Both girls have the same student loan expense and both girls set aside the same portion of their income for fun stuff, i.e. entertainment and looking nice.
 
Now Memphis girl has used up all of her income while NYC girl still has a little left, so she puts that into savings as well. Both girls are living very similar lives, NYC girl gets to dress fancier but we'll get to that in a minute. The real difference isn't affecting these girls today, it's when they go to retire, NYC girl will have twice the retirement account as Memphis girl so if they both go down to Florida to retire they are going to have very different retirement accommodations. The only way Memphis girl can ever hope to match this is if she buys her home while NYC girl rents, then she will have 5 years or no mortgage payment to divert to savings and be able to sell her home for cash. Now one or both of these girls might get married and have kids which would drastically change this model, but the point was to show the long term effects of the income  / tax/ cost of living gap.
 
On a personal level, this really put my love for designer clothes and accessories into perspective. I'm wanting a NYC wardrobe (ok, really a Palm Beach wardrobe) on a Memphis budget. Memphis is not perhaps less fashion sophisticated than bigger cities, it's just that a $300 purse is a bigger purchase here than it is elsewhere. Don't get me wrong, I still love my living situation in Memphis but I'm realizing it might not be the worst thing ever to consider moving one day.
 
Here's the actual numbers for my fellow math nerds if a visual helps.
 
    NYC Memphis
Income   100,000.00 55,000.00
       
Insurance   2,400.00 2,400.00
401K   6,000.00 3,300.00
Taxable   91,600.00 49,300.00
Taxes   24,598.60 8,254.00
NET   67,001.40 41,046.00
Expenses:       
Savings 10% 6,700.14 4,104.60
Housing   26,800.56 14,366.10
Transportation   7,300.00 6,980.00
Food   10,400.00 6,500.00
Student Loan   3,000.00 3,000.00
Entertainment 5% 3,350.07 2,052.30
Clothing and Beauty 10% 6,700.14 4,104.60
       
Additional Disposable   2,750.49 -61.60
       
       
Annual Savings   19,450.63 9,666.20
       
35 year    1,440,000.00 742,220.00
Inflation Adjustment   496,457.00 255,589.00

Comments

  1. Hm. This is an interesting comparison. Even CT to Memphis is an interesting comparison. It's cheaper to live in the South in general, but at the same time, the wages are lower. So it does somewhat even out at that level. Very interesting.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

And so it begins

I've been working on this post for awhile but I wasn't quite ready to share it with the world. Some of you might still be wondering why I'm sharing. Well we're married a year now, we bought the big house in the good school district so I know you're wondering - when are they going to have a baby. So now you don't have to feel awkward asking if we're trying to conceive (TTC) the answer is no - well not yet at least. Right now we're on a plan I'm referring to as pre-TTC.
My Pre-TTC tools - tracking planner, thermometer and prescription  It's awkward to be honest - there's lots of online groups and forums for women TTC but no one really talks about pre TTC, it's like you just wake up and one day say ok, we're now ready to have a baby. But as I've learned, it's really not that simple. I've had conversations with a very few people about this on one hand here I am bitching about how this is something that isn't talked abou…

Gratitude Challenge

So this month I was all set to do the whole gratitude challenge thing  but as I started to think of what things I might post about I started to think maybe this isn't the best idea. Is it possible to do a gratitude challenge and come up with 30 unique expressions of gratitude without humble bragging? My day to day life is pretty boring and we don't have cute kids that provide a constant supply of little daily antidotes to be grateful about and I know that this isn't about picking up 30 material possessions  in my life and posting about them. But even when I look past the "stuff" in my life and more behind emotional and non tangible things it still just doesn't feel right - does the friend with the sick kid really need my post about how #blessed I am with good health popping up in her feed? I think not. 
Maybe I'm being Debbie downer on what's supposed to be a lighthearted and fun social media engagement but I just can't get my heart into it becau…

Shelby Jewel

I really wanted to have this post up yesterday but if you've been following my instagram stories at all you will have seen that I remembered this weekend that I still needed to refinish my dining room table if I had any hopes of using it for Thanksgiving (and yes, I am on track to finish it tonight, Woohoo!) So here I am a day late but not a dollar short with a post on some fun fashion finds. Last week I attended the preview party for a new online boutique started by Memphis Blogger Shelby Jewel. Shelby has beautiful taste so I knew I was interested in checking out her boutique. Nothing says welcome like a glass of Champagne! Racks of beautiful tops Swoon worthy Jackets Pretty Tassel Earrings So, I'll admit I was very nervous about this event, Shelby is very small and most boutique sizes are small as well - I am not. But, I really wanted to see the pretty things and thought hey, you never know. As I predicted clothing is available in S - L but I have found that with some bou…

Thanksgiving Essentials

 Next week is Thanksgiving and I am soooo excited! Thanksgiving is basically all of my favorite things in one day - chilling in pjs watching the parade, delicious food, family time, and shopping! For the past few years we have gone our for Thanksgiving because the condo was not wheelchair friendly for my grandmother and my dad moved out of town but this year we're going back to having Thanksgiving at home and while I'm sad we won't have my grandma this year I am excited to be cooking the Thanksgiving meal again. In my humble opinion Thanksgiving is no time for healthy eating and since everyone has their own favorites I say bring on the carbs - this is what my menu this year will be: 1. Champagne Turkey 2. Stuffing 3. Green Bean Casserole 4. Sweet Potato Casserole 5. Mashed Potatoes 6. Peas 7. Corn Soufflé 8. Broccoli 9. Pillsbury Crescent Rolls 10. Cranberry sauce (from the can of course, I hate it but my family tells me this is the only way to have it) 11. Pie 12. Ma…

Vi Peel

Hello! So I got my first Vi Peel which I was super excited about. Since the Botox post was popular I figure y'all would like this too. Besides, it's well established I'm beyond any sense of privacy or shame here.
I got my first peel years ago - a mild Glycolic peel added onto my facial when I turned 23. Then a few years ago I went to a friends Botox party, I was 26 and scared of Botox at the time but I got a TCA peel and liked the results but not the price tag so I bought the solution online and started doing them myself. All was fine and dandy at home until I stopped following the instructions, opps. The peel was supposed to be applied with a cotton pad , I had the genius idea this past march to brush it on. It dripped and got too deep into my skin resulting on uneven peeling.
So I had to wait for that mess to heal before I could get it professionally fixed. I decided to switch to the vi peel because its supposed to be better and hurts less, tca literally produces tear…